EP is an honourable man, says the CPM at least for now. But its near-exoneration of EP Jayarajan, the party’s Central Committee member and Left Democratic Front convenor embroiled in the controversy over his meeting with BJP’s Kerala in-charge, Prakash Javadekar, begs more questions. Among them is: So, what about Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan’s proverb about Lord Shiva and the sinners? Has the infected lord been cleansed of the sins by the party? The CPM has again failed to give a convincing reply to the grave charges, increasing the suspicion that the party’s effort is to prevent more damaging revelations from surfacing.

On the face of it, the meeting between Jayarajan and Javadekar can hardly be called a crime. Will anyone shut the door on a visitor without reason, especially when he is a known political leader and a former Union minister? Will Congress’s V D Satheeshan or Ramesh Chennithala refuse to let Javadekar to their homes if he visits them? In fact, a mature and healthy democracy should brook personal interactions between leaders of rival political hues. It was strange to hear a senior news anchor repeatedly questioning what on earth Jayarajan and Javadekar should discuss other than politics when they meet.

However, it would be very different if Javadekar’s visit had to do with Jayarajan’s alleged moves to join the BJP. Yet, unless there is concrete proof for the claims -however sensational they are- made by BJP’s Sobha Surendran and “Dallal” Nandakumar, Jayarajan’s statement that he never discussed politics with Javadekar, let alone about his joining the BJP, should be taken at its face value. Neither is the charge that Jayarajan should have informed his party about his brief and impromptu rendezvous of any serious significance outside the party. Whether Jayarajan’s admission was ill-timed or not is also of concern only to his party. Neither has Javadekar said anything yet except to admit that he has met many leaders from different political parties. Certainly, the “J&J” controversy is a work in progress, and more dramatic revelations may crawl out soon. But let’s wait until then.

However, the meeting indeed raises serious concerns on another level, even at this stage. Chief Minister Vijayan did not hesitate a bit to respond without any ambiguity. “Jayarajan hasn’t been discreet when choosing his friends”. This was tantamount to a public censure against Jayarajan that the party usually issues only after the organisational process reserved for an errant comrade. Very rarely does Vijayan make statements about his party colleagues without considering the party’s organisational protocol. Neither was it common for him to admit the mistakes of his own or his comrades. Recall the latest incident when Vijayan defended P V Anwar, who gracelessly called for a DNA examination of Rahul Gandhi. Vijayan’s quoting what he called a proverb on Lord Shiva and sinners was also quite uncharacteristic of the Marxist strongman.

Public figures are often privileged to enjoy power, position, and limelight. However, in return, they are to let their private lives also be under the public scanner. Unlike private individuals, they cannot claim the luxury of privacy and are constantly accountable even for their private conduct, more so when it appears to transgress the Lakshman Rekha. Probity in public life demands transparency, accountability, and adherence to ethical standards in all actions and decisions of persons holding positions of authority or influence in the public sphere. Hence, they often face questions from the public or the media about their family, friends and even lovers. Jayarajan is very important in Kerala's political and social sphere as the LDF convener, a part of the state government, and a CPM’s Central Secretariat member. Therefore, he must explain to Kerala his friendship with T G Nandakumar, the self-styled power broker accused of associating with many unhealthy trends in Kerala’s politics. Jayarajan’s explanation is not just to establish his personal bona fides but the CPM and also the LDF he leads. Kerala has a right to know.

It is not the first time that Jayarajan has embarrassed CPM and LDF, notwithstanding his services and sacrifices for the party. His role, while associated with the party organ, to canvas advertisements or bonds from tainted sources, the case of nepotism that led to his leaving the previous Pinarayi ministry, his association with the environmentally disastrous tourism project and so on are examples. Wonder why the CPM hasn't reined in the leader until now? Or is Jayarajan only a symptom of a deeper malaise affecting the party, which has grown beyond cure? Or is it a fear that reining in Jayarajan may lead to a domino effect in the party?

The CPM’s exoneration of Jayarajan has made it incumbent on the party to explain what transpired between the two leaders. Vijayan’s initial response had given the impression that Jayarajan’s was a personal failing. Not anymore, particularly because CPM always poses itself as Sangh Parivar’s uncompromising opponent and never misses to dub (and rightly so often) the Congress as soft towards the saffron party. It becomes all the more critical when Sangh Parivar seems to be nearing its goal of breaking Kerala’s bipolar polity.

Far more menacing to Kerala than the Jayarajan issue was what unfolded during the election campaign in Vadakara. The personal hate and toxic communalism that raged there under the watch of the secular parties would shame even the rabid communalists. The region has been known in the past for such a perilous tradition, which was brought under control with difficulty by the leaders of CPM and the Muslim League, such as Kodiyeri Balakrishnan and P K Kunhalikkutty. However, the sleeping virus appears to have been reactivated by the current election. At a time when the Muslim community is under unprecedented duress in most parts of the country, it's critical for both the CPI-M and the League to show how Kerala is different. Instead, what their ranks did in Vadakara, fuelled by their respective cyber armies, was just the opposite. Hope the leaders of both parties still have leaders who can see the danger and act immediately.

6 min

Columns

View From My Window

Apr 23, 2024

6 min

Columns

View From My Window

Apr 15, 2024

6 min

Columns

View From My Window

Mar 30, 2024

4 min

Columns

View From My Window

Mar 17, 2024

5 min

Columns

View From My Window

Mar 11, 2024

QOSHE - Jayarajan & Javadekar: Sleeping with the enemy? - View From My Window
menu_open
Columnists Actual . Favourites . Archive
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close
Aa Aa Aa
- A +

Jayarajan & Javadekar: Sleeping with the enemy?

31 0
30.04.2024

EP is an honourable man, says the CPM at least for now. But its near-exoneration of EP Jayarajan, the party’s Central Committee member and Left Democratic Front convenor embroiled in the controversy over his meeting with BJP’s Kerala in-charge, Prakash Javadekar, begs more questions. Among them is: So, what about Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan’s proverb about Lord Shiva and the sinners? Has the infected lord been cleansed of the sins by the party? The CPM has again failed to give a convincing reply to the grave charges, increasing the suspicion that the party’s effort is to prevent more damaging revelations from surfacing.

On the face of it, the meeting between Jayarajan and Javadekar can hardly be called a crime. Will anyone shut the door on a visitor without reason, especially when he is a known political leader and a former Union minister? Will Congress’s V D Satheeshan or Ramesh Chennithala refuse to let Javadekar to their homes if he visits them? In fact, a mature and healthy democracy should brook personal interactions between leaders of rival political hues. It was strange to hear a senior news anchor repeatedly questioning what on earth Jayarajan and Javadekar should discuss other than politics when they meet.

However, it would be very different if Javadekar’s visit had to do with Jayarajan’s alleged moves to join the BJP. Yet, unless there is concrete proof for the claims -however sensational they are- made by BJP’s Sobha Surendran and “Dallal” Nandakumar, Jayarajan’s statement that he never discussed politics with Javadekar, let alone about his joining the BJP, should be taken at its face value. Neither is the charge........

© Mathrubhumi English


Get it on Google Play