The World Bank has a Logistics Performance Index (LPI) with a focus on trade logistics. This is based on six heads of customs, infrastructure, international shipments, logistics competence, tracking and tracing, and timeliness. As is the case with every index, especially when data are based on subjective responses to questionnaires, methodology can always be questioned and improved. In the 2023 LPI, India is ranked 38 out of 139 countries. In 2014, India was ranked 54. Despite possible caveats about LPI, it is obvious that logistics performance has improved and the goal has also been clearly articulated in 2022: “Targets for achieving the vision of the National Logistics Policy are to (i) reduce cost of logistics in India to be comparable to global benchmarks by 2030; (ii) improve the Logistics Performance Index ranking — endeavour is to be among top 25 countries by 2030; and (iii) create data driven decision support mechanism for an efficient logistics ecosystem.” In addition, there is PM Gati Shakti, which was launched in 2021. Because of understandable time lags, the impact of this doesn’t show in LPI 2023, but will, eventually.
A cross-country ranking of logistics performance is one thing, estimating logistics cost is another. Economic Survey 2022-23 told us, “logistics costs in India have been in the range of 14-18 per cent of GDP against the global benchmark of 8 per cent.” That kind of range floats around. In 2018, there was a port logistics report by Dun and Bradstreet (D&B), which found that the cost of doing business at sea ports was around 15-16 per cent of the consignment value — there was wide variation across ports. Before the Economic Survey 2022-23, in 2020, there was a CII-Arthur D Little report on India’s supply chain. To quote, “logistics costs in the Indian supply chain amount to almost USD 400 billion, or 14 per cent of GDP. A comparison with global peers shows that logistics costs amount to 8-10 per cent of GDP in the US and Europe, and 9 per cent in China. The global average is close to 8 per cent of GDP, which reveals a competitiveness gap of USD 180 billion for India… Other South-Asian countries, such as Thailand and Vietnam, also have high logistics costs. These countries’ costs reach 14 and 16-17 per cent of GDP, respectively.” The D&B methodology was clear. In any event, it computed the cost of doing business as a percentage of the consignment value. But when it comes to logistics costs such as the percentage of GDP, since methodology isn’t clearly explained, numbers seem to be plucked out of thin air.
This brings one to a recent (December 2023) report by NCAER on logistics cost in India. This is precise in its methodology and estimation. To quote from this paper, “in the context of India, there are no official estimates for logistics costs as a percentage of GDP. However, private sector institutions and academic institutions have computed logistics costs, which are widely quoted to stress the point that India is a country with high logistics costs.” In addition to the ones I mentioned earlier, NCAER cites three — Armstrong and Associates (2017), an estimate of 13 per cent of GDP; CII (2015), an estimate of 10.9 per cent of GVA; and NCAER (2019), an estimate of 8.9 per cent of GVA. Clearly, there are variations in what is being measured and how. This new NCAER report uses supply and use tables. What does it find? In 2021-22, logistics costs had an estimated range of between 7.8 per cent and 8.9 per cent. In 2014-15, they had an estimated range of between 8.3 per cent and 9.4 per cent. There has been a decline over time (with a transient increase in 2017-18 and 2018-19). It cannot be anyone’s case that this new NCAER report is the last word on the subject. But it is a beginning, with a clear methodology. And two points emerge: First, logistics costs aren’t as bad as they are often made out to be, and second, they have declined over time (also evident from LPI).
Logistics, good or bad, are driven by states and the commerce ministry has a LEADS (Logistics Ease Across Different States) report based on perceptions. The 2023 version was released in December. Since states are heterogenous in the reporting, they are divided into four groups — coastal, landlocked, north-east and UTs. States that do well are called achievers. Nomenclature matters. Thus, states that are middling aren’t called average. They are called fast movers. States that are sub-par are called aspirers. Let me highlight coastal states, since 75 per cent of export cargo is estimated to originate from them. Among coastal states, the ones that do well are Andhra Pradesh, Gujarat, Karnataka and Tamil Nadu. The ones that lag are Goa, Odisha and West Bengal. While India’s logistics performance may have improved over time, that’s not true of every state. Some have slipped. Most states have a state-level logistics policy, including Goa and Odisha. West Bengal, bottom of the pecking order in the coastal category, doesn’t have one. To quote from LEADS 2023, “looking ahead, the state (West Bengal) could benefit from formulating a State Logistics Master Plan and State Logistics Policy to drive efficiency improvements and facilitate investments within the logistics sector and undertake consultation with the logistics stakeholders for educating and informing them about the initiatives state is undertaking for the development and improvement of logistics sector.”
Logistics has been talked about for a long time and India has also focused on improving performance. We are now getting some precise data on measurement and quantification. That helps.
The writer is chairman, Economic Advisory Council to the Prime Minister
Did your salary beat the inflation rate in Modi years?Premium Story
UPSC Key, January 10: What to read today and whyPremium Story
What the animal world teaches fathers about raising childrenPremium Story
Is the Earth becoming warmer?Premium Story
By sending Bilkis convicts back to jail, SC reasserts itsPremium Story
Ex-envoy: ISI tipped off India about plot to hit KashmirPremium Story
UPSC Key, January 9: What you should read today andPremium Story
Why do politicians rush to give direct benefits (cash) toPremium Story
The true story of the Jolly Joseph casePremium Story
Uma Bharti interview: ‘We've no copyright on Ram Bhakti'Premium Story
‘Badalta Kashmir’: Meet rappers whose song on Valley is makingPremium Story
Problems MAX: Why Alaska Airlines incident raises concern globallyPremium Story
Tavleen Singh writes: Mixing religion with politics has ruined countriesPremium Story
Accurate data is the first step in bringing down logistics costs in India
10
1
11.01.2024
The World Bank has a Logistics Performance Index (LPI) with a focus on trade logistics. This is based on six heads of customs, infrastructure, international shipments, logistics competence, tracking and tracing, and timeliness. As is the case with every index, especially when data are based on subjective responses to questionnaires, methodology can always be questioned and improved. In the 2023 LPI, India is ranked 38 out of 139 countries. In 2014, India was ranked 54. Despite possible caveats about LPI, it is obvious that logistics performance has improved and the goal has also been clearly articulated in 2022: “Targets for achieving the vision of the National Logistics Policy are to (i) reduce cost of logistics in India to be comparable to global benchmarks by 2030; (ii) improve the Logistics Performance Index ranking — endeavour is to be among top 25 countries by 2030; and (iii) create data driven decision support mechanism for an efficient logistics ecosystem.” In addition, there is PM Gati Shakti, which was launched in 2021. Because of understandable time lags, the impact of this doesn’t show in LPI 2023, but will, eventually.
A cross-country ranking of logistics performance is one thing, estimating logistics cost is another. Economic Survey 2022-23 told us, “logistics costs in India have been in the range of 14-18 per cent of GDP against the global benchmark of 8 per cent.” That kind of range floats around. In 2018, there was a port logistics report by Dun and Bradstreet (D&B), which found that the cost of doing business at sea ports was around 15-16 per cent of the consignment value — there was wide variation across ports. Before the Economic Survey 2022-23, in 2020,........
© Indian Express
visit website
login
who are we?
contact us
qosheapp
Toi Staff
Gideon Levy
Belen Fernandez
Mort Laitner
Rami G Khouri
Ali Fathollah-Nejad
Nikkei Editorial
