With the ongoing investigation into the “black sands diaries”, the infamous saga of Kerala’s beach sands that contain highly explosive radioactive elements and their no less explosive political and financial linkages are making headlines again.

The century-long history of Kerala’s black sand mining has been marked by the forces that shaped the 20th century. They range from global advances in science and technology to colonialism, capitalism, nazism, communism, nationalism, World Wars, the nuclear bomb, the Cold War and also the native royalty’s foiled ambitions to create an independent Thiruvithamkoor state.

The invaluable natural wealth, embedded in the black sands of the coastal stretch from Kanyakumari to Alappuzha, was among the world’s best rare earths, in quantity and quality. The monazite and ilmenite-rich sands’ industrial and strategic potential made rich Western nations compete against each other to court Thiruvithamkoor from the early 20th Century. Had they been used with greater vision and intelligence, these sands would have catapulted Kerala as one of the world’s richest regions, just as oil made the Gulf countries prosperous. Instead, they became a murky battleground of vested interests driven by narrow political and economic ambitions that left Kerala and its people benefit far less than what was potentially possible.

Sir C P Ramaswami Iyer, the visionary but autocratic dewan of Thiruvithamkoor, was the first indigenous administrator to identify the sands' economic, industrial and strategic utility and their consequent political significance. However, to be fair to him, even while obstinate whims and excessive political ambitions drove him, Thiruvithamkoor’s economic interests were CP’s priority. He believed the region's spices and minerals would ensure prosperity for an independent Thiruvithamkoor. When thorium, an element of monazite, became a much sought-after nuclear fuel globally in the mid-1940s, CP found a golden opportunity for Thiruvithamkoor, which held its world’s largest deposits in its beach sands. The demand for thorium sky-rocketed as the nuclear race heated up between global powers with the onset of World War II. CP thought there could be no better bargaining chip to realise his dream of an independent Thiruvithamkoor.

Thiruvithamkoor’s mineral sands have been mined since the beginning of the 20th century. The region’s famed coir products have been in high demand in the West since the 19th century. Their weight assessed the value of coir products, and cunning exporters from Alappuzha soaked them in seawater to make them weigh more. The story goes that in 1909, a German chemist and entrepreneur, P.W. Schomberg chanced upon some beach sands on a coir product from Thiruvithamkoor, and he understood they contained monazite. Electricity was still rare, and thorium was used widely to make gas mantles, invented by Germans for incandescent lighting. Schomberg, a partner in the London Cosmopolitan Mining Company, soon arrived in Thiruvithamkoor looking for monazite. Schomberg set up the Travancore Minerals Company as a subsidiary of the London company and opened factories in Manavalakkurichi near Nagercoil and Chavara in Kollam.

The First World War changed global geopolitical equations. Britain turned hostile to Germany, and Schomberg was arrested in 1911, suspected as a German spy. Subsequently, British firms Hopkin and Williams, Thorium Ltd and later an American company, Lindsay Lights & Chemicals, began extraction in Thiruvithamkoor and exported unprocessed sands to Britain and the USA. During that time, almost all the monazite imported by these countries came from Thiruvithamkoor. But, by the war's end, the mineral demand crashed as electricity widely replaced gas for lighting needs.

In 1936, the formidable Sir CP took over first as an advisor and later as dewan in Thiruvithamkoor. Next year, Frederick Soddy, the Nobel-winning English chemist who, with Ernest Rutherford, explained the nature of radioactivity, visited Sri Lanka (then Ceylon) and Thiruvithamkoor to study rare earth deposits. Soddy told CP about the enormous industrial and economic potential of Thiruvithamkoor’s monazite-rich beach sands.

The 1930s witnessed a new rise in global demand for monazite again. This followed the discovery that thorium, an element of monazite, could be used as nuclear fuel like uranium. With the Second World War breaking out and the race for nuclear weapons hotting up, thorium became the hottest and most strategic raw material. The Allied powers did not just want to stockpile it by amassing it from across the world but also block it from entering German hands. The 1945 bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki by the USA proved its fierce utility beyond all doubt.

As the war was ending, CP ordered an embargo on monazite export “except for essential war needs”. CP’s decision shocked the American firm the most, which imported 3000 tons annually from Thiruvithamkoor. They even threatened to block sales of all thorium-based products to India, writes Itty Abraham, a professor at Arizona State University with Malayali roots, in his fascinating essay, Rare Earths: The Cold War in the Annals of Travancore (1998).

However, CP was unrelenting and insisted the mining companies set up processing plants in Thiruvithamkoor instead of fully exporting the sands. Passionate about industrialising the kingdom, he knew the companies made huge profits through typical colonial extraction. The processed thorium fetched the companies far more than Thiruvithamkoor received from them as royalty. After much hesitation, only Thorium Ltd agreed to set up a processing factory.

In the 1940s, STR, a big monazite processing company in Nazi-occupied France, also processed monazite imported from Thiruvithamkoor. According to a recent book (Ploughshares and Swords: India's Nuclear Program in the Global Cold War, 2022) by Jayita Sarkar of Cornell University, “though it is unlikely, it was not impossible” that Travancore’s monazite had ended up for Nazi Germany’s war needs through the pro-Nazi STR. She says that through the Chicago-based Lindsay Lights, the monazite from Thiruvithamkoor reached the Manhattan Project also, which produced the first nuclear bomb.

By the mid-1940s, the British were on their way out from India. Thiruvithamkoor was among the four princely states that refused to join the Union of India after independence. CP firmly believed Thiruvithamkoor was prosperous enough to stay independent. He even decided to have an envoy in the soon-to-be-born Pakistan, struck deals with Burma for rice imports and discussed with American mills to produce clothes for Thiruvithamkoor. These were in response to the interim Prime Minister Nehru’s threat to choke Thiruvithamkoor of all supplies if it chose to be independent. Nehru sent troops to the other states wanting independence and threatened an airstrike on Thiruvithamkoor.

To bolster his own hands, CP began wooing Britain and the USA, dangling the mineral sands. By then, the Cold War was on, and the Western powers feared the Soviet Union eyeing India's strategic materials with the Socialist Nehru’s backing. CP’s hate for Communists demonstrated in his violent repression of the Punnapra Vayalar uprising, also made them see him as an ally. The USA by then was already active in India to checkmate Communism and also neighbouring China.

However, CP’s hopes crashed when Nehru, Patel, Mountbatten and VP Menon moved in collectively. KN Bamzai, Nehru's friend and a journalist with Blitz, a left-wing journal, exposed CP’s secret moves with the British and the USA. The details of this are available in the book -Princestan: How Nehru, Patel and Mountbatten Made India- authored by Bamzai’s grandson, Sandeep Bamzai.

In June 1947, Nehru deputed Homi Bhabha, “the father of India’s nuclear programme”, accompanied by scientist Shanti Swarup Bhatnagar, to Thiruvananthapuram to discuss with CP and the king to ensure the entire Thiruvitamkoor’s monazite be delivered to the newly independent India’s atomic programme. CP agreed to form the India-Travancore-India Joint Commission on Atomic Energy but insisted Thiruvithamkoor had sovereign ownership over its sands.

Menon also warned CP that the Indian government might be unable to help in the likely event of a Communist uprising in the reds-infested Thiruvithamkoor if it remained independent. Interestingly, VD Savarkar, the Hindutva hero, hastened to back CP in his endeavour. So much for the Hindutva deshbhakti!

On 18 June 1947, Thiruvithamkoor’s king, Balarama Varma, announced his decision not to join India and remain independent. But on July 25’s night, KCS Mani, a young Socialist Revolutionary, attacked CP with a dagger as he was entering his car after attending a music concert. Many’s adventure was intended to punish CP for his autocratic ways. The grievously injured dewan’s life was saved by a whisker, and he immediately left for good to his native Madras. A week later, the young Maharaja Chithira Tirunal Balarama Varma announced his kingdom's accession to the Union of India.

However, the lucrative “karimanal” fields continued to be a haven for corruption and exploitation even after popular governments took over. An article authored by N Sreekantan Nair, a top trade unionist, during the early 1950s, lamented: “ The sand factories are synonymous with sleaze and sex. Workers are paid a pittance while middlemen make big money. The inept government has failed to tap the sands’ immense economic potential.” As they say, the more things change, the more they stay the same.

1 min

News

Nri

Feb 21, 2024

1 min

News

Kerala

Feb 21, 2024

1 min

News

Kerala

Feb 19, 2024

2 min

News

Kerala

Feb 19, 2024

6 min

Columns

View From My Window

Feb 18, 2024

6 min

Columns

View From My Window

Dec 24, 2022

QOSHE - Karimanal: A Century-long Murky Saga  - View From My Window
menu_open
Columnists Actual . Favourites . Archive
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close
Aa Aa Aa
- A +

Karimanal: A Century-long Murky Saga 

14 1
26.02.2024

With the ongoing investigation into the “black sands diaries”, the infamous saga of Kerala’s beach sands that contain highly explosive radioactive elements and their no less explosive political and financial linkages are making headlines again.

The century-long history of Kerala’s black sand mining has been marked by the forces that shaped the 20th century. They range from global advances in science and technology to colonialism, capitalism, nazism, communism, nationalism, World Wars, the nuclear bomb, the Cold War and also the native royalty’s foiled ambitions to create an independent Thiruvithamkoor state.

The invaluable natural wealth, embedded in the black sands of the coastal stretch from Kanyakumari to Alappuzha, was among the world’s best rare earths, in quantity and quality. The monazite and ilmenite-rich sands’ industrial and strategic potential made rich Western nations compete against each other to court Thiruvithamkoor from the early 20th Century. Had they been used with greater vision and intelligence, these sands would have catapulted Kerala as one of the world’s richest regions, just as oil made the Gulf countries prosperous. Instead, they became a murky battleground of vested interests driven by narrow political and economic ambitions that left Kerala and its people benefit far less than what was potentially possible.

Sir C P Ramaswami Iyer, the visionary but autocratic dewan of Thiruvithamkoor, was the first indigenous administrator to identify the sands' economic, industrial and strategic utility and their consequent political significance. However, to be fair to him, even while obstinate whims and excessive political ambitions drove him, Thiruvithamkoor’s economic interests were CP’s priority. He believed the region's spices and minerals would ensure prosperity for an independent Thiruvithamkoor. When thorium, an element of monazite, became a much sought-after nuclear fuel globally in the mid-1940s, CP found a golden opportunity for Thiruvithamkoor, which held its world’s largest deposits in its beach sands. The demand for thorium sky-rocketed as the nuclear race heated up between global powers with the onset of World War II. CP thought there could be no better bargaining chip to realise his dream of an independent Thiruvithamkoor.

Thiruvithamkoor’s mineral sands have been mined since the beginning of the 20th century. The region’s famed coir products have been in high demand in the West since the 19th century. Their weight assessed the value of........

© Mathrubhumi English


Get it on Google Play