Not many government programs have been proven so counter-productive. Nava Kerala Sadas (NKS) was launched to celebrate the LDF government’s second anniversary, highlight its achievements, and expose the central government’s discrimination. NKS was intended to counter the growing mood of anti-incumbency as seen in the media on account of the spate of scams that have embroiled the government and re-establish its legitimacy. But the results have proved just the opposite. Seldom has a government appeared more intolerant, undemocratic, and vindictive to its opponents when the NKS comes to a grinding halt after 36 eventful days.

As an idea, NKS was quite admirable. The entire cabinet led by the Chief Minister, getting out of the rarefied zone of power in the state’s secretariat and traveling together continuously for more than a month across the state to meet and talk to people hasn’t happened before anywhere. Even though the exercise was more symbolic than substantive, it indeed was in line with the tradition of decentralisation of power in which the Kerala Left has much to claim. NKS’s second achievement was in the people’s participation. Those who assess NKS based only on what they read or saw about it in the media may equate it to the slew of ugly clashes and controversies that accompanied it along the way. The mass attendance was impressive, notwithstanding the party’s or government's machinery that may have made it possible. (However, it was cringy to hear ministers themselves claiming how immensely fortunate people were to get an opportunity to meet them all together.)

Sadly, the positives end there. One indeed should appreciate Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan’s incredible energy, despite his below-par health, shown in the half-an-hour-long speeches and combative press conferences he held on every one of the 36 days with clockwork precision. Yet, did his speeches and repartees go beyond the routine harangues and statements the government and its representatives have made since they came to power? Besides, thanks to the fisticuffs on the way, the CM was forced to spend much time not just explaining but even justifying them, which made things only terribly worse. The conflicts between a restive SFI and the hot-headed Governor Arif Mohammed Khan that broke out when the NKS was going on also damaged the peace on the streets.

The most difficult question that the NKS faced was about its profligacy. Right from the luxury coach in which the ministry travelled or the sumptuous breakfast meetings with the prominent invitees, the programme appeared as an extravaganza. Imagine that the very idea of ministers collectively traveling in the common people’s transport instead of their official limousines was to demonstrate how close they were with the common folk! Instead, the bus trip turned out to look much more extravagant than the ministers travelling in their own vehicles. It even appeared to be a criminal waste at a time when Kerala was going through an unprecedented financial crisis that deprived the most depressed sections of their subsistence pensions. The expenses could have been justified if it was proved to be an investment to make people’s lives better in the future. The worst irony was that the NKS’s prime intention was to show how the central government was choking Kerala financially!

Unlike that of a political party, it is grossly unethical for a government to hold such a program using public money if it is not intended to directly benefit the people substantially. The first bummer came when it was decided that common people attending the NKS could submit their grievances or memorandums only to the officials and not the ministers. This actually threw a spanner in the works of the very spirit of the programme, touted as the grand mass contact exercise in which the cabinet went to the people to hear and solve their grouses. Things got worse when, even as the common folk were denied an audience with the ministers, “prominent persons” of each region were specially invited to have breakfast with them. One imagined that it was the Left who understood most of the rancor and resentment resulting from inequality and discrimination.

The next shocker was when Thomas Chazhikadan, MP, was publicly admonished by the CM for raising a few long-pending needs of the Kottayam district in his welcome speech. The CM said the programme wasn't meant for what the MP did. But if not for addressing public needs, what was in the NKS for the people? According to the CM, that activity should be confined to officials receiving submissions from the public. By then, the chance of public demands getting direct attention from the cabinet was buried. Yet, thousands of submissions were received from each constituency. Government sources say every submission was given receipts and that the CM has strictly instructed them to be seriously addressed within a prescribed time frame. Hopefully, it doesn't face the fate of the countless submissions raised by the non-residents at the Loka Kerala Sabha. In the meanwhile, Minister V N Vasavan staked his claim to be Kerala’s D K Barooah - the Emergency era Congress President of “India is Indira” notoriety- by stooping to a new depth in sycophancy by calling Pinarayi Vijayan a “gift of god” and the ground he set his foot on as “blessed.”

Whatever is mentioned above is not entirely new to Kerala. But the unprecedented, shocking, and most abominable part was the wanton violence repeatedly inflicted on the protestors all the way along the NKS by CPI(M) workers, police, and even the CM’s personal protection staff. Only its shocking justification by the CM as a “life-saving act,” and his call for an encore was even more uncivilized. Despite all other claims, this will be etched in public memory for a long time as the lasting legacy of Nava Kerala yatra and its leader. Hopefully, the Nava Keralam we bequeath to our coming generations will not be the one we had the misfortune to witness during the NKS.



4 min

Columns

View From My Window

Dec 17, 2023

6 min

Columns

View From My Window

Dec 6, 2023

4 min

Columns

View From My Window

Nov 14, 2023

4 min

Columns

View From My Window

Nov 4, 2023

5 min

Columns

View From My Window

Oct 28, 2023

7 min

Columns

View From My Window

Dec 1, 2023

4 min

Columns

View From My Window

Dec 17, 2023

6 min

Columns

View From My Window

Dec 6, 2023

6 min

Columns

View From My Window

Sep 2, 2023

QOSHE - The bleak Nava Keralam - View From My Window
menu_open
Columnists Actual . Favourites . Archive
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close
Aa Aa Aa
- A +

The bleak Nava Keralam

11 0
27.12.2023

Not many government programs have been proven so counter-productive. Nava Kerala Sadas (NKS) was launched to celebrate the LDF government’s second anniversary, highlight its achievements, and expose the central government’s discrimination. NKS was intended to counter the growing mood of anti-incumbency as seen in the media on account of the spate of scams that have embroiled the government and re-establish its legitimacy. But the results have proved just the opposite. Seldom has a government appeared more intolerant, undemocratic, and vindictive to its opponents when the NKS comes to a grinding halt after 36 eventful days.

As an idea, NKS was quite admirable. The entire cabinet led by the Chief Minister, getting out of the rarefied zone of power in the state’s secretariat and traveling together continuously for more than a month across the state to meet and talk to people hasn’t happened before anywhere. Even though the exercise was more symbolic than substantive, it indeed was in line with the tradition of decentralisation of power in which the Kerala Left has much to claim. NKS’s second achievement was in the people’s participation. Those who assess NKS based only on what they read or saw about it in the media may equate it to the slew of ugly clashes and controversies that accompanied it along the way. The mass attendance was impressive, notwithstanding the party’s or government's machinery that may have made it possible. (However, it was cringy to hear ministers themselves claiming how immensely fortunate people were to get an opportunity to meet them all together.)

Sadly, the positives end there. One indeed should appreciate Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan’s........

© Mathrubhumi English


Get it on Google Play