Umpteen are incidents of the state using force to repress opposition in Kerala as everywhere else. The pre-independence period witnessed the most brutal of them, like the 1946 firing in Punnapra Vayalar which accounted for the highest casualties. If the royal government of Thiruvithamkoor was the architect of that tragedy, the British Indian government was responsible for the next most gruesome incident- the Wagon Tragedy. While the Punnapra Vayalar firing took a toll of more than 200 (unofficially more than 1000), nearly 70 persons arrested in connection with the Malabar rebellion were choked to death in the second incident. The wagon tragedy took place while the arrested were being transported by the police from Tirur to Podanur by cramming them inside a closed railway carriage in 1921. These were only the worst among the numerous dark incidents of state-sponsored violence in pre-independence Kerala.

With independence and the establishment of democracy, governments elected by the people became more restrained, responsible, and tolerant. That doesn't mean that state brutality ended forever. Many ugly incidents occurred under most democratic governments irrespective of parties. The firing that took the highest toll in post-independent Kerala occurred in 1959 under the state’s first elected government led by the CPI. Seven persons were killed in that incident when police opened fire at anti-government (Vimochana Samaram) protesters in Angamaly. Next on the dismal list in terms of casualties is the 1994 police firing at Koothuparamba which took the lives of five CPI(M) youths who were trying to protest against Minister M V Raghavan of the UDF government.

Though casualties were less, there were many other incidents of firing, police beatings, custodial deaths, etc under various governments including the dramatic atrocities during the Emergency rule. A major police firing that occurred since then was in 2008 in Beemapally in Thiruvananthapuram which killed six persons. But it was not against anti-government protests but to prevent communal violence.

There has been a marked reduction in police brutality since the past two decades notwithstanding the killing of seven Maoists in “encounters”. Water cannons have largely replaced rifles and batons. Many ascribe this change to a reformation that has come about within the police force from top to bottom with time, changed concepts about policing and the increasing induction of those with better education. For the first time in history, a top police official even publicly stated recently that the force was not bound to obey the illegal orders of superiors. But there are some other important reasons too; the advent of 24-hour news channels, social media, and smartphones fitted with cameras that have turned every citizen into a watchdog and every act brought sharply under the public scanner. Even K Karunakaran, the dreaded Home Minister during the Emergency who believed in giving unlimited freedom to police never defended publicly the misdeeds of the period.

Another significant change brought about by democracy and self-rule is the governments' and rulers’ largely desisting from attempts to justify the violence from their forces unlike the royalty or the colonizer. They either tried to disown, distance, or at worst, defended the violence only as an unavoidable last resort.

This has been the case with political violence as well. Once openly glorified, the victims used to be celebrated as martyrs or balidanis by the respective parties which have also seen a political investment in them. Indeed, such martyrdom and revenge continue to be extolled in places like Kannur having a culture and tradition of bloodshed as celebrated in the region’s folk arts like theyyam or the northern ballads. Yet, such remnants of a tribal past are now slowly but surely being seen as antithetical to the practices of modern democracy.

It is in this context that the shocking justification by Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan of CPI(M) workers’ bashing up those who tried to wave black flags at the bus carrying the cabinet members for Nava Kerala Sadas marks a major step backward for the state. Vijayan not only justified the hooliganism but even openly encouraged to repeat such actions which is an open call to the party cadre to take the law into their hands. This blatant and unprecedented exhortation raises serious constitutional questions as it has come from the state’s Chief Minister who has assumed office by taking an oath to protect the rule of law. Taking a cue from the Chief Minister, other ministers too remarked that the protestors deserved the beating. The emergence of vigilante forces to back state security forces to crush the opposition is a common feature of authoritarian states. Examples are Hitler’s Brown Shirts, Mussolini’s Black Shirts, or the volunteers of Indian rightwing outfits who killed Gowri Lankesh, Narendra Dhabholkar, Govind Pansare, and MM Kalburgi.

The vigilant attack on protesters is now followed by yet another shocking incident of the Chief Minister’s gunmen and bodyguards pounding on and thrashing the black flag-waving protestors with long sticks on the streets in Alappuzha. Such blatant atrocities in full public glare have been common only in the so-called bad lands of the Hindi heartland. Even more condemnable was the Chief Minister justifying this patently illegal action too with impunity. As if this wasn’t enough, a Congress leader’s house in Alappuzha was ransacked and his wife shoved by CPI(M) workers. Kerala has been set back by many years by these incidents.

It is a sad state for Kerala that the other high ranking-functioning of the state is also involved in extremely blatant constitutional violations and nakedly partisan or even childish pranks. With his ego bruised and battered by the Supreme Court’s sharp admonition against him for sitting on the ordinances sent by the state government, Governor Arif Mohammed Khan has thrown out all the norms of decency and decorum expected from his exalted constitutional position. After constantly rebuking - and rightly so- the state government for trying to fill up university posts with party nominees, Khan who is the Chancellor, has merrily packed the seats with BJP people. The way the 73-year- old Khan settles scores with young students for protesting against him by jumping out of his official car to take them on in the streets or choosing to stay in Calicut University Guest House to defy them would only ensure his place as the most immature, and divisive governor in Kerala history.

Cry, my beloved country.

6 min

Columns

View From My Window

Dec 6, 2023

4 min

Columns

View From My Window

Nov 14, 2023

4 min

Columns

View From My Window

Nov 4, 2023

5 min

Columns

View From My Window

Oct 28, 2023

4 min

Columns

View From My Window

Oct 15, 2023

6 min

Columns

View From My Window

Dec 6, 2023

7 min

Columns

View From My Window

Dec 1, 2023

6 min

Columns

View From My Window

Sep 2, 2023

QOSHE - When Chief Minister and Governor pull down Kerala  - View From My Window
menu_open
Columnists Actual . Favourites . Archive
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close
Aa Aa Aa
- A +

When Chief Minister and Governor pull down Kerala 

9 5
19.12.2023

Umpteen are incidents of the state using force to repress opposition in Kerala as everywhere else. The pre-independence period witnessed the most brutal of them, like the 1946 firing in Punnapra Vayalar which accounted for the highest casualties. If the royal government of Thiruvithamkoor was the architect of that tragedy, the British Indian government was responsible for the next most gruesome incident- the Wagon Tragedy. While the Punnapra Vayalar firing took a toll of more than 200 (unofficially more than 1000), nearly 70 persons arrested in connection with the Malabar rebellion were choked to death in the second incident. The wagon tragedy took place while the arrested were being transported by the police from Tirur to Podanur by cramming them inside a closed railway carriage in 1921. These were only the worst among the numerous dark incidents of state-sponsored violence in pre-independence Kerala.

With independence and the establishment of democracy, governments elected by the people became more restrained, responsible, and tolerant. That doesn't mean that state brutality ended forever. Many ugly incidents occurred under most democratic governments irrespective of parties. The firing that took the highest toll in post-independent Kerala occurred in 1959 under the state’s first elected government led by the CPI. Seven persons were killed in that incident when police opened fire at anti-government (Vimochana Samaram) protesters in Angamaly. Next on the dismal list in terms of casualties is the 1994 police firing at Koothuparamba which took the lives of five CPI(M) youths who were trying to protest against Minister M V Raghavan of the UDF government.

Though casualties were less, there were many other incidents of firing, police beatings, custodial deaths, etc under various governments including the........

© Mathrubhumi English


Get it on Google Play