Tweet Share Share Comment

“The world knows me as Graham v. Florida,” says Terrence Graham. “I just want people to know that there’s more to Graham v. Florida than just a case.”

Graham was 17 years old when a Florida judge sentenced him to die in prison. He was 37 when he came home last month.

Graham was the plaintiff in the 2010 landmark Supreme Court decision that found that sentencing juveniles to life in prison without parole for nonhomicide offenses constitutes cruel and unusual punishment, a violation of the 8th Amendment. It was one of a series of Supreme Court decisions that reflected an evolving understanding by courts that kids are different.

In 2002, when Graham was 16, he was charged with armed burglary as an adult after he and two other teenagers robbed a Jacksonville restaurant. The charge carried a possible life sentence, but he took a plea deal and was given credit for time served in county jail and put on probation. Six months later, just a month short of his 18th birthday, he committed a home invasion.

At his 2006 sentencing hearing for that crime, a Florida judge told the then 19-year-old that he had squandered his second chance: “It is apparent to the Court that you have decided that this is the way you are going to live your life and that the only thing I can do now is to try and protect the community from your actions.”

The judge could have given him five years, but instead sentenced Graham to the maximum: life without the possibility of parole.

Advertisement

Eight years later his case would be in front of the Supreme Court on appeal. The justices would find that sentence unconstitutional, noting that “it does not follow that [Graham] would be a risk to society for the rest of his life.”

The majority opinion noted that at the time, there were 129 juveniles convicted of nonhomicides who were serving sentences of life without parole across the country, a significant majority of whom (77) were serving sentences in Florida.

Advertisement

Advertisement

Advertisement

Following the Supreme Court decision, in 2012 Graham’s original judge in Florida resentenced him to 25 years in prison—the maximum sentence allowed.

Over his 20-year incarceration, Graham earned his GED, took college classes, and found solace in his faith. He’s passionate about family, sports, and prison reform. He also co-founded Plead the 8th, a nonprofit working to end the incarceration of children in Florida’s adult system.

Advertisement

The state ranks third in the country for the number of individuals who have been incarcerated since they were kids—around 2,600. Graham’s case and others only led to resentencing for youth who were sentenced to life without the possibility of parole, not those who have other extreme sentences.

As he seeks to restart his life, I spoke with Graham about the moment he realized the significance of his case and what life is like reentering society as an adult after going to prison as a child. This interview has been edited for length and clarity.

Charlotte West: What do you want people to know about who you are and what you’re up to now?

Terrence Graham: I came from a broken family. I had a rough background, but that didn’t define me. I never said that I was innocent from the crime that I committed. But I always felt like the sentence that I had was too harsh for a child. But it also helped me develop the character that I have today.

Advertisement

Advertisement

These three weeks of me being out, I’ve been learning how to readjust to life all over again. I left society as a child, and now I’m out here experiencing life for the first time as an adult.

What has reentry been like?

I hit the ground running when I got out. I’m working two jobs and fighting for prison reform, so I’m trying to keep myself occupied. I’m learning how to build industrial fans, and I help my mom cleaning buildings at night. We got our own cleaning service business that we started two years ago.

Advertisement

There are certain things that if I didn’t have the family support, if I didn’t have good friends able to help me navigate, I’d be lost. As part of the reentry program, they give you bus passes, but by me being on this ankle monitor, with a GPS system, sometimes it loses signal. If that happens, you need to go back to the house. So you can’t just tell the bus to stop and turn around and take you home. And that can possibly become a violation. So that’s one of the things that I fear. So I’ve been getting rides from my family back and forth to work.

Advertisement

Advertisement

Advertisement

What are some of the challenges that you’re facing right now with house arrest and probation?

I’m staying now at a transition house. And it’s me and three other guys. So my family are allowed to come visit me, but I’m not allowed to go and visit them. I have elderly people in my family, such as my grandma who’s 91 years old, staying in a nursing home. I just pray daily that I get to see her here in the free world before she passes. I can’t leave the house but to go to work and church. I get to go to the store and the barber shop once a week. I have to fill out a weekly report of where I’m going to be and when. Basically, I left one form of confinement for another.

Advertisement

But it’s still a blessing. To be told that this will never happen, like me standing out here in the yard right now at night, that’s something that I couldn’t even have imagined would come about.

And you’ve also got to pay fines and fees for the community supervision?

Advertisement

With fees and fines right now, I have to pay off $11,000 before I can get off of probation. That’s over the course of five years, I pay like $200 a month. I’m on community control [house arrest] for two years.

Advertisement

Back when you received your sentence at the age of 19, did you realize the gravity of the judge’s words?

When they gave me that sentence, I knew that life meant life, but I never really sat down and accepted it. From the time that I got to the prison system, I had started researching my case, going to the law library, reaching out to an appeal attorney. I mean, I went through some dark moments. With that sentence over my head, I’m not gonna say that it was a cakewalk, because it wasn’t. There was times where I cried at night because I was like, Wow, I’ll never be able to talk my mom again. Or I’ll never be able to be out there with my grandfather and my grandmother. Some of those things I still won’t ever be able to do because my granddad passed away while I was in there. So it’s a lot of people that was here when I left and they didn’t get to see this day come.

Advertisement

Going back to 2010, when did you realize what a big deal the Supreme Court decision was?

I had got papers in the mail, but I didn’t know that the Supreme Court was going to affect how the world sees juveniles sentenced as adults. I was sitting in the prison day room, and when the world news came on and popped up talking about this Supreme Court landmark case, Graham v. Florida, and they showed my picture. Everybody’s like, “Man, look at your case, this is big.”

Advertisement

Advertisement

Advertisement

The next day, it ended up being published in USA Today. And it got published in almost every newspaper in the United States. And even at that time, when all that was going on, I didn’t understand that it was making history. All I knew was that I was going to get a chance to get my freedom again at some point.

Advertisement

You were resentenced in 2012, but you still had more than a decade to serve. But many other people benefited from your case and got out before you did. How did you maintain a positive attitude?

When I went back and got resentenced in 2012 and they took the life sentence off of me, I had such high hopes that I was gonna walk out of the courtroom right then because of all of the media exposure and everything. So when the judge took the life off of me and he sentenced me to 25 years, that hurt me worse than the life sentence.

My positive attitude is actually by the grace of God. It was a struggle sometimes to be able to see people being released off of your case and yet you still remain in there. I just started praying. My time came when it came, and it was 20 years later. A lot of those guys was incarcerated way before me, they had 20, 30, 40 years. They deserve that chance too. It’s just a blessing to be able to be the reason that they can be reunited with their family.

Advertisement

When and why did you get your GED and start pursuing an education?

Related From Slate

Adam Gershowitz

The Surprising Downside of a Criminal Justice Trend Reformers Might Think They Love

Read More

I got my GED in 2008 for my family. I remember at first I was rebellious towards the staff for making me go to school when I wanted to review my case in the law library. They kept writing me disciplinary reports and putting me in the box [solitary confinement]. I turned 21 and then it was my choice to attend school.

Advertisement

Popular in News & Politics

  1. Content Locked for Slate Plus members

    Even the Supreme Court’s Conservatives Are Fed Up With the Garbage Coming Out of the 5th Circuit
  2. Stormy Daniels Is Telling a Different, Darker Story Than She Used To
  3. So Trump’s Trial Delay Tactics Really Worked, Huh?
  4. John Roberts Just Dropped the Hammer on Rogue, Lawless Trump Judges

I was in the box when my first appeal got denied [in 2008] and it felt like I was being sentenced to life all over again. I wrote my mom and brother and they were like, “Please don’t give up. Pray and focus on God if you want your freedom!” So that’s what made me want to get my GED and enroll into college. I was the first of my mom’s kids to graduate and the only child of hers to even enroll into college despite me being in prison. It felt good to be doing something good instead of just being her child that’s in prison.

What makes you hopeful about the future?

Advertisement

I met a lot of good guys in there that will never get a chance to get out here in the free world. So I’m living for them as well. Since I’ve been out, I’ve been trying all these different foods just to try to figure out what’s my favorite food, or just trying to find a show on TV to say, “This is my show.” So it’s just a whole bunch of me trying to learn life out here.

Any conclusions yet?

It’s all been good. I’ve been eating prison food with no seasoning for 20 years. So to come out here to taste my mom’s home-cooked spaghetti and lasagna, I can’t even decide which one is the best. There’s a whole lot of food I haven’t tried yet. But I will let you know.

Tweet Share Share Comment

QOSHE - The Supreme Court Struck Down His Sentence 14 Years Ago. He Only Just Got Out Now. - Charlotte West
menu_open
Columnists Actual . Favourites . Archive
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close
Aa Aa Aa
- A +

The Supreme Court Struck Down His Sentence 14 Years Ago. He Only Just Got Out Now.

6 0
19.03.2024
Tweet Share Share Comment

“The world knows me as Graham v. Florida,” says Terrence Graham. “I just want people to know that there’s more to Graham v. Florida than just a case.”

Graham was 17 years old when a Florida judge sentenced him to die in prison. He was 37 when he came home last month.

Graham was the plaintiff in the 2010 landmark Supreme Court decision that found that sentencing juveniles to life in prison without parole for nonhomicide offenses constitutes cruel and unusual punishment, a violation of the 8th Amendment. It was one of a series of Supreme Court decisions that reflected an evolving understanding by courts that kids are different.

In 2002, when Graham was 16, he was charged with armed burglary as an adult after he and two other teenagers robbed a Jacksonville restaurant. The charge carried a possible life sentence, but he took a plea deal and was given credit for time served in county jail and put on probation. Six months later, just a month short of his 18th birthday, he committed a home invasion.

At his 2006 sentencing hearing for that crime, a Florida judge told the then 19-year-old that he had squandered his second chance: “It is apparent to the Court that you have decided that this is the way you are going to live your life and that the only thing I can do now is to try and protect the community from your actions.”

The judge could have given him five years, but instead sentenced Graham to the maximum: life without the possibility of parole.

Advertisement

Eight years later his case would be in front of the Supreme Court on appeal. The justices would find that sentence unconstitutional, noting that “it does not follow that [Graham] would be a risk to society for the rest of his life.”

The majority opinion noted that at the time, there were 129 juveniles convicted of nonhomicides who were serving sentences of life without parole across the country, a significant majority of whom (77) were serving sentences in Florida.

Advertisement

Advertisement

Advertisement

Following the Supreme Court decision, in 2012 Graham’s original judge in Florida resentenced him to 25 years in prison—the maximum sentence allowed.

Over his 20-year incarceration, Graham earned his GED, took college classes, and found solace in his faith. He’s passionate about family, sports, and prison reform. He also co-founded Plead the 8th, a nonprofit working to end the incarceration of children in Florida’s adult system.

Advertisement

The state ranks third in the country for the number of individuals who have been incarcerated since they were kids—around 2,600. Graham’s case and others only led to resentencing for youth who were sentenced to life without the........

© Slate


Get it on Google Play