The only thing as predictable as global warming causing more storms and more power outages is the political debate that follows.
Transmission lines wrecked by Tuesday’s wild weather.Credit: Jason South
After Tuesday’s storms and blackouts in Victoria came Wednesday’s press releases from Canberra. Familiar positions were rapidly occupied and defended.
Nationals leader David Littleproud issued a statement arguing that the collapse of transmission towers carrying power from Loy Yang in south-eastern Victoria underscored the vulnerability of Labor’s plan to replace the nation’s ageing coal power stations with renewable power generation and storage projects distributed across the country.
“If small-scale nuclear power plants were built where retiring coal-fired power stations are now, we could minimise the need for new transmission lines, reducing the risk of these incidents,” he said.
Opposition spokesman on climate change and energy, Ted O’Brien, also an advocate of nuclear, criticised Labor’s “blinkered renewables only” approach to rebuilding the grid, saying Australia needed an “electricity system resilient to the weather, not reliant on it”.
The opposition’s case is that if we replace our clapped-out coal stations with small modular nuclear reactors on the same sites, we would obviate the need to replace the transmission lines they use. This would save money and reduce the need for extra transmission lines that would be needed to move power in a grid where generation is more widely spread over the countryside.
The problem with this argument – aside from the fact these reactors don’t yet exist – is that however power may be generated at the old power stations, it would still need to be moved to the cities.
If Loy Yang had been producing nuclear power on Tuesday, the grid would still have been threatened by a storm that took down transmission lines to it.
Wind or sun, coal or nuclear; we need a stronger grid and a better debate
7
1
14.02.2024
The only thing as predictable as global warming causing more storms and more power outages is the political debate that follows.
Transmission lines wrecked by Tuesday’s wild weather.Credit: Jason South
After Tuesday’s storms and blackouts in Victoria came Wednesday’s press releases from Canberra. Familiar positions were rapidly occupied and defended.
Nationals leader David Littleproud issued a statement arguing that the collapse of transmission towers carrying........
© The Sydney Morning Herald
visit website
login
who are we?
contact us
qosheapp
Toi Staff
Gideon Levy
Belen Fernandez
Rami G Khouri
Mort Laitner
Donald Low
Ali Fathollah-Nejad
Nikkei Editorial
