Given the very recent defeat of the Indigenous Voice referendum, an interesting feature of past weeks has been the significant amount of money allocated to the Northern Territory. Two weeks ago, we saw a joint announcement between the federal and Territory governments of $4 billion for remote housing. The next day, another joint announcement: $1 billion on schools, with disadvantaged schools to get the cash first.
Last Monday, Indigenous Affairs Minister Linda Burney made these points in an answer she gave in question time on the topic of violence in Indigenous communities. By Wednesday, the issue of violence in the Northern Territory more generally had become national news, with a state of emergency declared, and a temporary nighttime curfew announced for under-18s in Alice Springs. That day, in response to a question from Peter Dutton about crime in Alice Springs, Anthony Albanese again mentioned the housing money.
Illustration: Jim PavlidisCredit:
Were the nation suddenly to decide violence up north was its most pressing priority, it’s possible these investments would not immediately strike voters – accustomed to politicians who pander to their fears – as the most convincing answer. The same might go for other things Albanese and Burney could justifiably have mentioned – such as the government’s increase to JobSeeker last year. As writer and researcher Eleanor Hogan has previously noted, crime in Alice Springs fell when JobSeeker rose, and rose when JobSeeker fell. This makes sense: the connection between crime and inequality is well known.
It seems unlikely Dutton would accept this response either – or that he would applaud if Labor suddenly announced another increase to JobSeeker. Which is a reminder of the gaps that always exist in politics. Journalist Paige Taylor perceptively noted last week that at the press conference where the NT curfew was announced, it was the person not at the mercy of voters, the police commissioner, who began emphasising long-term solutions as the real answer. Taylor made this point in relation to Indigenous affairs, but it is the reality of governing more broadly: short-term emergencies often arise from long-term factors, which means that urgent action is unavoidable, but rarely the answer.
This gives rise to a damaging rhetorical gap too: between the things one might say today and the things that could be helpful in building a different perception of the problem in the long run.
And then there is the more obvious gap: between the needs of a government and the needs of an opposition.
In April, the High Court will hear a case about whether an asylum seeker who has refused to co-operate with his deportation can be kept in detention. If the court frees him then, according to the Guardian, another 170 or so asylum seekers might also be freed, adding to the 151 freed by the court’s decision last November.
This would create a difficulty for the government, as constitutional law expert Anne Twomey has written: an incentive for asylum seekers not to co-operate with deportation. And so, last week, the government attempted to pass new laws. As Twomey explained, if the government loses the case, the new laws – should they pass – will, in effect, allow anybody freed by the decision to be locked up again for the criminal offence of refusing to co-operate with deportation.
The PM was punching well, until he gave himself an immigration uppercut
7
0
31.03.2024
Given the very recent defeat of the Indigenous Voice referendum, an interesting feature of past weeks has been the significant amount of money allocated to the Northern Territory. Two weeks ago, we saw a joint announcement between the federal and Territory governments of $4 billion for remote housing. The next day, another joint announcement: $1 billion on schools, with disadvantaged schools to get the cash first.
Last Monday, Indigenous Affairs Minister Linda Burney made these points in an answer she gave in question time on the topic of violence in Indigenous communities. By Wednesday, the issue of violence in the Northern Territory more generally had become national news, with a state of emergency declared, and a temporary nighttime curfew announced for under-18s in Alice Springs. That day, in response to a question from Peter........
© The Sydney Morning Herald
visit website
login
who are we?
contact us
qosheapp
Toi Staff
Gideon Levy
Belen Fernandez
Andrew Mitrovica
Mort Laitner
Rami G Khouri
Ali Fathollah-Nejad
Nikkei Editorial
