Credit: Getty Images.

Like the poor, shoplifters have always been with us, since the first little marketplace was set up in front of the first complex of caves, probably somewhere on Long Island.

Suffice to say, shoplifting has history. It’s a part of the well-established price of doing business that shops large and small through the ages have dealt with, to varying degrees of success, and that featured for the longest time far more draconian consequences for those caught at it than are socially acceptable today. Still, its been considered no more than a background murmur in our daily lives for generations.

So why are we in 2024 being told that suddenly there’s a national, and state, clanging crisis brought on by the newest iteration of shoplifting on steroids – retail theft? Drums are being beaten on the subject in Washington and in the capitals of most states in the nation, telling us we have a big problem.

Advertisement

Article continues below this ad

Here in New York, Gov. Kathy Hochul has made taking on retail theft a major priority of her administration this legislative session. A bill before the lawmakers would create a well-funded task force headed by our State Police, and I suspect we can anticipate an increased police presence in the marketplace as well.

But is there really a crisis? Maybe. A genuine concern justifying the governor’s emphasis on it and her task force? Absolutely.

But why do we think there might be a crisis?

Because major retailers across the country are saying so. They point to billions in lost inventory to "shrinkage," which includes shoplifting. But a deep dive into the evidence these retailers present does not produce any confidence in their numbers. These retailers are shy on providing specifics, apparently for proprietary reasons, and because shrinkage also includes employee theft, security problems with self checkout, warehouse and shipping theft and a host of other inventory control problems.

Advertisement

Article continues below this ad

Which is not to suggest the retailers are deceiving us about the negative effects of retail theft, or the increase in plain old shoplifting. A better gauge of the extent is looking at arrest records for petit larceny, which since the mid-pandemic have been steadily rising to record levels.

Significant, as are the spectacular smash-and-grab daylight robberies in stores that have garnered deserved attention as well.

Bear in mind that when big retailers like Target or Walgreen’s complain that shrinkage is getting out of control, every politician in the country pays attention, and so does the public. It’s political dynamite. The loss of a store for such a reason would be a major blow to any community, both for the goods and services it provides but also as a concrete symbol of the failure of public safety.

Which brings us to why we seem to have a significant concern in 2024 brought on by a degree of retail theft that we have not experienced before.

Advertisement

Article continues below this ad

Consider it a trifecta. When the emboldened criminally inclined intersect with a lack of accountability for their actions and the rewards of those actions considerably exceed their risks, you get the mess we’re in. Of course the last is just a refinement of accountability. Which is the point of all this. We have dropped the ball on accountability.

Hold on. I can see my progressive friends getting all frothy. Let me emphasize that I exclude those shoplifters acting out of the Big Three: mental illness, addiction or poverty. Initially, they get a pass to treatment, alternative courts and all the resources their individual situations require. It those resources exist, if they are funded to sufficient levels. I will save for another day exploring that morass of failures, or what’s to be done to those who just slip through the system and are turned loose again and again and get rearrested tomorrow, or again the next day. A truism, though, is that rarely do any of us fall into neat, handy categories.

Still, I am singling out retail thieves who are in it as a career. They are around and in numbers, and they are apparently becoming more brazen and more violent and consequently belong in jail. If that means upgrading a misdemeanor to a felony, so be it. Overdue.

Assembly Speaker Carl Heastie has made it clear he will not entertain any more reforming of the bail laws. Sorry Mr. Speaker, but reality keeps overrunning your position. And as for state Democratic chair Jay Jacobs telling the Times Union we’ve done all we have to do with bail reform and its time to move on, I would only suggest he has about as much standing to set public policy as the average cab driver.

Advertisement

Article continues below this ad

Last year judges in the state were given a great deal more discretion for setting bail for even low-level offenses, including for multiple charges of shoplifting. However, a recent analysis by this newspaper of how judges have used that discretion for setting bail or letting them walk showed a wide disparity.

Bottom line is, if you get that urge to lift, consider Manhattan, the Bronx or Albany, but better stay away from Buffalo and Rochester..

QOSHE - Fred LeBrun: The golden age of shoplifting - Fred Lebrun
menu_open
Columnists Actual . Favourites . Archive
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close
Aa Aa Aa
- A +

Fred LeBrun: The golden age of shoplifting

6 1
11.02.2024

Credit: Getty Images.

Like the poor, shoplifters have always been with us, since the first little marketplace was set up in front of the first complex of caves, probably somewhere on Long Island.

Suffice to say, shoplifting has history. It’s a part of the well-established price of doing business that shops large and small through the ages have dealt with, to varying degrees of success, and that featured for the longest time far more draconian consequences for those caught at it than are socially acceptable today. Still, its been considered no more than a background murmur in our daily lives for generations.

So why are we in 2024 being told that suddenly there’s a national, and state, clanging crisis brought on by the newest iteration of shoplifting on steroids – retail theft? Drums are being beaten on the subject in Washington and in the capitals of most states in the nation, telling us we have a big problem.

Advertisement

Article continues below this ad

Here in New York, Gov. Kathy Hochul has made taking on retail theft a major priority of her administration this legislative session. A bill before the lawmakers would create a well-funded task force headed by our State Police, and I suspect we can anticipate an increased police presence in the marketplace as well.

But........

© Times Union


Get it on Google Play