An Indigenous player allegedly called a rival player “white scum” during an NRL match last season — but the matter went nowhere because there was no audio of the incident and the opposition club had no interest in making a complaint.

The NRL confirmed to this column that the club had taken the incident to its wellbeing and education department, not the Integrity Unit, and suggested further education was needed around the language being used on the field.

When the NRL asked the club if it wanted to make a complaint, it declined. Because there was no audio nor vision of the incident, the NRL didn’t pursue it further.

The Herald has decided not to name the players nor clubs involved because the player who allegedly made the remark was not charged, and there is no proof the comment was made.

There’s also no value in rehashing the same circular debate like the one around Matildas captain Sam Kerr and allegations she called a London police officer a “stupid white bastard” after a night out last year.

Yet, the incident raised with the NRL is worth discussion as it reveals the racial fractures that exist in rugby league.

Spencer Leniu (right) of the Roosters exchanges heated words with Kotoni Staggs of the Broncos in Las Vegas.Credit: Getty

That’s something that has been painfully exposed by Roosters prop Spencer Leniu’s “monkey” comment to Broncos five-eighth Ezra Mam and the subsequent reaction of Polynesian players who say they have brushed off on-field racist remarks for years — and even consider the use of such language as “banter”.

The NRL judiciary on Monday night banned Leniu for eight matches. Manly and Tongan international Haumole Olakau’atu thought it was too much. Retired North Queensland star Johnathan Thurston argued “the game has failed” Indigenous Australians. He wanted 12.

Privately, the Roosters are less concerned about Leniu spending two months on the sidelines – he did, after all, plead guilty – than the judiciary flatly rejecting his claim that he didn’t understand the term “monkey” was racist.

“The panel did not accept the player’s claimed ignorance that he was not aware that ‘monkey’ was, when used towards the Indigenous community, a racist term,” the judiciary chairman, the Honourable Justice Geoff Bellew SC, said.

The game is fortunate to have someone of Bellew’s intellect and standing – a Supreme Court judge no less - running an eye over such important matters, but the findings against Leniu were brutal. The judiciary essentially ruled he was a liar trying to squirm his way out of a long-term suspension.

Of course, there’s no place for racism in the game. It’s sad the point still needs to be made.

What the events of the past fortnight have shown is the game, like never before, is a melting pot of cultures, each with its own set of values and language. Rugby league’s diversity is often celebrated – but it also means worlds will inevitability collide.

That was rarely more evident than midway through the 2022 season when seven Manly players refused to take the field on religious grounds because their club wanted them to play in a jersey that had rainbow-coloured piping that wasn’t specifically supportive of the LBGT community but “everyone in league”.

Manly forward Haumole Olakau’atu.Credit: James Brickwood

What’s happened between Leniu and Mam – and the loose commentary that has followed – is another example of two cultures not understanding each other.

One of the more confronting moments during Monday night’s hearing came when Leniu revealed that some players of colour use derogatory, racist terms when speaking to each other. He said players joked about who was “blacker”, along with a range of insults all said in jest. For those in the room, it was uncomfortable to hear, but Leniu rattled them off like it was a second language.

When I was told last week this type of linguistic reappropriation – similar to when African-Americans call themselves “n---a” or gay men reference themselves as “f----t” - would form part of Leniu’s defence, I was stunned.

Do players really talk like that? Surely not.

Brisbane five-eighth Ezra Mam.Credit: AP

Then I called a handful of coaches at other clubs who confirmed this dynamic existed within their teams. Asked why they would allow it, the response was the same: “Who am I, as a white man, to tell these players how to talk to one another?”

Asked on Tuesday about this very topic, Olakau’atu said: “We do use those words for banter, and for a laugh, we don’t use it for anything else, or have any emotions behind it.”

When I suggested to the NRL last week this dynamic was at play in some clubs, it was quickly dismissed. Clearly, though, it’s something that needs addressing, from both the league and clubs.

Revelations from Leniu and Olakau’atu that they had been called “coconut” at various times during their NRL careers but have become desensitised to such slurs were equally troubling.

The game needs to do far better than that, something NRL chief executive Andrew Abdo acknowledges.

“We have strength from cultural diversity in rugby league and in Australia,” he said. “We should never stop listening and learning from each other and most importantly do so with deep respect.”

Wests Tigers coach Benji Marshall.Credit: Rhett Wyman

Well, this is different: Wests Tigers coach Benji Marshall is copping it in the neck for not working hard enough - before their first match of the season.

Marshall said last year that he wasn’t going to be a “24-7 coach”, thereby giving the impression he’s taking a casual approach.

I’ve interviewed Marshall for a lengthy piece in Saturday’s Herald and I asked him about this. Many coaches are obsessives, rolling out of bed at 2am to pore over video because they can’t sleep.

Others, like Penrith coach Ivan Cleary, seem to understand the importance of balance. It doesn’t mean they care less, just differently.

“You need an element of being a lunatic,” Marshall told me.

Is he a control freak?

“Far from it,” he said. “I do like separating coaching and family. I’ll put boundaries in place for my family. I like to pick my kids up from school once or twice a week. Once I get home from training, I don’t answer the phone until the kids and wife go to bed.

“On family days off, unless it’s an emergency, I’ll put it all into my family. I encourage my players to do the same. My message to them is family is the most important thing in life. Don’t make footy the most important thing.”

When the cricket cognoscenti found itself in a tizz last summer about who should replace David Warner as Australia’s Test opener, I posed the question in this very space: would Matthew Hayden have had a second coming under the current regime that entirely ignores domestic form?

If the sheer volume of runs scored in the Sheffield Shield meant anything, surely Cameron Bancroft – a specialist opener – deserved another chance, even if it might make for some dressing-room awkwardness because of the lingering pong of Sandpaper-gate.

Steve Smith is bowled during the Test series against New Zealand.Credit: AP

But no! What would a rugby league hack know? Stay in your lane.

The selectors went with Steve Smith, who was desperate for a new “challenge”, and now it’s blown up in their face.

Apart from his unbeaten 91 against the West Indies in Brisbane, he’s barely troubled the scorers in eight innings over four Tests.

Cameron Bancroft playing for Western Australia.Credit: Getty

Sure, the pitches in New Zealand were bowler-friendly but scores of 31, 0, 11 and 9 - an average of 12.75 - against a team ranked fifth in the world doesn’t cut it.

SEN broadcaster Gerard Whateley was bang on when he said: “It’s no longer a small sample size. There’s enough to judge. In that configuration, it lacks chemistry and it lacks runs and I don’t think Australia would get away with it against India.”

The problem is, Australia won’t play any red-ball cricket between now and December when the Border-Gavaskar Trophy gets underway. So it will surprise if they make any change.

Captain Pat Cummins and coach Andrew McDonald didn’t want Smith to be promoted to the top of the order, although quickly changed their tune.

Maybe they were onto something.

THE QUOTE
“I don’t know which chin I’m supposed to hit.” — Former Storm and Raiders bad boy Curtis Scott, who conceded almost 30 kilograms to former Roosters, Knights, Raiders, and Tigers bad boy Joey Leilua in their fight in Wollongong on Wednesday night. Scott knocked him out in the second.

THUMBS UP
Funny old game, cricket. One minute, Australia wicketkeeper Alex Carey looks like he’s about to be axed, having struggled with the bat since the Jonny Bairstow stumping. The next, he’s pulling the second Test against New Zealand out of the proverbial fire with an unbeaten 98 as his side secured a three-wicket victory.

THUMBS DOWN
After watching Western Sydney Wanderers’ diabolical 7-0 loss to Melbourne City — the heaviest defeat in club history — coach Marko Rudan refused to front the obligatory post-match media conference, leaving it to assistant Jean-Paul de Marigny to face the music.That made Rudan a bigger story than the loss.

It’s a big weekend for … Wests Tigers teenage prodigy Lachlan Galvin, an Australian Schoolboy and yet another product of Westfields Sports High, who makes his NRL debut against Canberra at GIO Stadium on Saturday. If the raps on him are to be believed, it could be one of those “where were you moments”. (Answer: sitting on my lounge at home, probably in my undies).

It’s an even bigger weekend for … Kurtley Beale, the former Wallaby who will play his first match of competitive rugby in more than a year when he lines up for Randwick against Queensland club Brothers in Brisbane this Saturday. It could help the 35-year-old find his way back into a Waratahs jumper after he successfully defended himself against sexual assault charges.

NRL is Live and Free on Channel 9 & 9Now

Sports news, results and expert commentary. Sign up for our Sport newsletter.

QOSHE - ‘White scum’: The racial fractures and clash of cultures the NRL must address - Andrew Webster
menu_open
Columnists Actual . Favourites . Archive
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close
Aa Aa Aa
- A +

‘White scum’: The racial fractures and clash of cultures the NRL must address

8 0
14.03.2024

An Indigenous player allegedly called a rival player “white scum” during an NRL match last season — but the matter went nowhere because there was no audio of the incident and the opposition club had no interest in making a complaint.

The NRL confirmed to this column that the club had taken the incident to its wellbeing and education department, not the Integrity Unit, and suggested further education was needed around the language being used on the field.

When the NRL asked the club if it wanted to make a complaint, it declined. Because there was no audio nor vision of the incident, the NRL didn’t pursue it further.

The Herald has decided not to name the players nor clubs involved because the player who allegedly made the remark was not charged, and there is no proof the comment was made.

There’s also no value in rehashing the same circular debate like the one around Matildas captain Sam Kerr and allegations she called a London police officer a “stupid white bastard” after a night out last year.

Yet, the incident raised with the NRL is worth discussion as it reveals the racial fractures that exist in rugby league.

Spencer Leniu (right) of the Roosters exchanges heated words with Kotoni Staggs of the Broncos in Las Vegas.Credit: Getty

That’s something that has been painfully exposed by Roosters prop Spencer Leniu’s “monkey” comment to Broncos five-eighth Ezra Mam and the subsequent reaction of Polynesian players who say they have brushed off on-field racist remarks for years — and even consider the use of such language as “banter”.

The NRL judiciary on Monday night banned Leniu for eight matches. Manly and Tongan international Haumole Olakau’atu thought it was too much. Retired North Queensland star Johnathan Thurston argued “the game has failed” Indigenous Australians. He wanted 12.

Privately, the Roosters are less concerned about Leniu spending two months on the sidelines – he did, after all, plead guilty – than the judiciary flatly rejecting his claim that he didn’t understand the term “monkey” was racist.

“The panel did not accept the player’s claimed ignorance that he was not aware that ‘monkey’ was, when used towards the Indigenous community, a racist term,” the judiciary chairman, the Honourable Justice Geoff Bellew SC, said.

The game is fortunate to have someone of Bellew’s intellect and standing – a Supreme Court judge no less - running an eye over such important matters, but the findings against Leniu were brutal. The judiciary essentially ruled he was a liar........

© WA Today


Get it on Google Play