Need something to talk about? Text us for thought-provoking opinions that can break any awkward silence.ArrowRight
One of these guys has managed, with admirable boldness and skill, to establish himself as a viable alternative to his party’s embattled front-runner.
The other guy is actually a declared candidate for president.
Look, I’m really not trying to kick DeSantis while he’s down — it’s just that he’s given us so few opportunities to kick him while he’s up. A onetime House member who sounds for all the world as if he still belongs there, DeSantis radiates smallness — not just as a presence onstage, but in spirit and intellectual depth, too.
There’s no mystery, given his disappointing poll numbers, as to why DeSantis jumped at the chance to go one-on-one with a Democrat who isn’t on any ballot anywhere. It’s a last, desperate audition for the part of Republican standard-bearer — the logical successor to presidents Ronald Reagan and George W. Bush — before resuming his recurring role as Nikki Haley’s whiny little brother at next week’s debate in Tuscaloosa, Ala.
Advertisement
But if DeSantis’s calculus is painfully clear, then Newsom’s is more opaque. Newsom has insisted that he supports President Biden and isn’t running some kind of shadow campaign. Which is true, I guess, in the sense that there doesn’t seem to be anything shadowy about it.
Follow this authorMatt Bai's opinionsFollow
In just the past few months, Newsom, a vigorous 56, has met with Chinese President Xi Jinping at the Great Hall of the People (looking conspicuously presidential in one of those awkward upholstered chairs); traveled to Israel to comfort survivors of the Hamas attack; and met with a bevy of world leaders at the Asia Pacific Economic Cooperation Leaders’ Summit in his hometown of San Francisco.
He also jumped to the forefront on regulating artificial intelligence, directing state agencies to look at how they use the technology and how to control it — a not-so-subtle move to cast himself as a futuristic thinker, reminiscent of a young Gary Hart or Bill Clinton.
Advertisement
All of which prompted Sen. John Fetterman (D-Pa.) to publicly say what a lot of irritated Democrats have been privately grumbling about — that Newsom was running against Biden but didn’t have the “guts” to declare it.
Because, apparently, having guts in the Democrat Party right now means mindlessly cheerleading for the president and hoping, despite all available data and the ominous mood, that everything is going to work out just fine.
Here’s the reality: Whether you like Biden or not (I do, and I’m pretty sure Newsom does, too), the Democratic Party right now is taking a shockingly reckless gamble with the country’s future. The oldest president in history is about to become an even older nominee, backstopped by a vice president whom barely a third of the country likes. For the next year, we will all be one major health issue, or one small slip on the stairs, from inviting a lying autocrat back to the White House.
Advertisement
The Democratic answer to all of this has been some version of: “Don’t worry, we’ve got this.” Which might sound familiar to you, since it’s precisely what Hillary Clinton’s strategists told everyone in 2016, when they tried, mostly with success, to shut down support for anyone who dared to run against her. That worked out great.
The party this time had plenty of strong potential candidates — governors such as Michigan’s Gretchen Whitmer, senators such as Georgia’s Raphael G. Warnock, Cabinet secretaries such as Pete Buttigieg and Gina Raimondo. But all of them stood down and pretended there was nothing weird about renominating an 81-year-old man with a 39 percent approval rating. Among party members in good standing, only an obscure congressman, Dean Phillips, has offered token resistance.
But here comes Newsom, who near as I can tell is the only serious Democrat willing to do the responsible thing. Newsom isn’t challenging Biden outright or seeking to upend the party, which is fine. He’s just setting himself up as a clear option, should an option be needed before the convention.
Advertisement
As the governor of one of the nation’s largest states, he’s got every right to position himself as a fallback. Someone has to.
Democratic voters ought to watch the Newsom-DeSantis debate, if they can manage to find Fox News in the channel lineups on their streaming apps. They ought to assess Newsom’s skills and his command of the issues, just in case they should wake up one day and find themselves in the market for an alternative to Biden who isn’t named Harris. That’s not me being mean or ghoulish. That’s being practical, and even patriotic.
I suspect viewers will see a polished politician, perhaps a bit too slick, who can nonetheless articulate a next-generation agenda and who isn’t willing to delude himself into thinking everything will be okay just because loyalty to the president demands it.
In Democratic politics at the moment, that’s about as brave as it gets.
Share Comments
Popular opinions articles
HAND CURATED
- Opinion|Here’s how to think about a cease-fire in GazaNovember 5, 2023Opinion|Here’s how to think about a cease-fire in GazaNovember 5, 2023
- Opinion|The Passion of George SantosNovember 27, 2023Opinion|The Passion of George SantosNovember 27, 2023
- Opinion|How to end plastic pollution on Earth for goodNovember 27, 2023Opinion|How to end plastic pollution on Earth for goodNovember 27, 2023
View 3 more stories
Loading...
Fox News is set to air the most intriguing debate of this presidential campaign season Thursday, when Sean Hannity hosts a showdown between two governors who really can’t stand each other — Florida’s Ron DeSantis and California’s Gavin Newsom.
One of these guys has managed, with admirable boldness and skill, to establish himself as a viable alternative to his party’s embattled front-runner.
The other guy is actually a declared candidate for president.
Look, I’m really not trying to kick DeSantis while he’s down — it’s just that he’s given us so few opportunities to kick him while he’s up. A onetime House member who sounds for all the world as if he still belongs there, DeSantis radiates smallness — not just as a presence onstage, but in spirit and intellectual depth, too.
There’s no mystery, given his disappointing poll numbers, as to why DeSantis jumped at the chance to go one-on-one with a Democrat who isn’t on any ballot anywhere. It’s a last, desperate audition for the part of Republican standard-bearer — the logical successor to presidents Ronald Reagan and George W. Bush — before resuming his recurring role as Nikki Haley’s whiny little brother at next week’s debate in Tuscaloosa, Ala.
But if DeSantis’s calculus is painfully clear, then Newsom’s is more opaque. Newsom has insisted that he supports President Biden and isn’t running some kind of shadow campaign. Which is true, I guess, in the sense that there doesn’t seem to be anything shadowy about it.
In just the past few months, Newsom, a vigorous 56, has met with Chinese President Xi Jinping at the Great Hall of the People (looking conspicuously presidential in one of those awkward upholstered chairs); traveled to Israel to comfort survivors of the Hamas attack; and met with a bevy of world leaders at the Asia Pacific Economic Cooperation Leaders’ Summit in his hometown of San Francisco.
He also jumped to the forefront on regulating artificial intelligence, directing state agencies to look at how they use the technology and how to control it — a not-so-subtle move to cast himself as a futuristic thinker, reminiscent of a young Gary Hart or Bill Clinton.
All of which prompted Sen. John Fetterman (D-Pa.) to publicly say what a lot of irritated Democrats have been privately grumbling about — that Newsom was running against Biden but didn’t have the “guts” to declare it.
Because, apparently, having guts in the Democrat Party right now means mindlessly cheerleading for the president and hoping, despite all available data and the ominous mood, that everything is going to work out just fine.
Here’s the reality: Whether you like Biden or not (I do, and I’m pretty sure Newsom does, too), the Democratic Party right now is taking a shockingly reckless gamble with the country’s future. The oldest president in history is about to become an even older nominee, backstopped by a vice president whom barely a third of the country likes. For the next year, we will all be one major health issue, or one small slip on the stairs, from inviting a lying autocrat back to the White House.
The Democratic answer to all of this has been some version of: “Don’t worry, we’ve got this.” Which might sound familiar to you, since it’s precisely what Hillary Clinton’s strategists told everyone in 2016, when they tried, mostly with success, to shut down support for anyone who dared to run against her. That worked out great.
The party this time had plenty of strong potential candidates — governors such as Michigan’s Gretchen Whitmer, senators such as Georgia’s Raphael G. Warnock, Cabinet secretaries such as Pete Buttigieg and Gina Raimondo. But all of them stood down and pretended there was nothing weird about renominating an 81-year-old man with a 39 percent approval rating. Among party members in good standing, only an obscure congressman, Dean Phillips, has offered token resistance.
But here comes Newsom, who near as I can tell is the only serious Democrat willing to do the responsible thing. Newsom isn’t challenging Biden outright or seeking to upend the party, which is fine. He’s just setting himself up as a clear option, should an option be needed before the convention.
As the governor of one of the nation’s largest states, he’s got every right to position himself as a fallback. Someone has to.
Democratic voters ought to watch the Newsom-DeSantis debate, if they can manage to find Fox News in the channel lineups on their streaming apps. They ought to assess Newsom’s skills and his command of the issues, just in case they should wake up one day and find themselves in the market for an alternative to Biden who isn’t named Harris. That’s not me being mean or ghoulish. That’s being practical, and even patriotic.
I suspect viewers will see a polished politician, perhaps a bit too slick, who can nonetheless articulate a next-generation agenda and who isn’t willing to delude himself into thinking everything will be okay just because loyalty to the president demands it.
In Democratic politics at the moment, that’s about as brave as it gets.
login
who are we?
contact us
qosheapp
Toi Staff
Gideon Levy
Belen Fernandez
Rami G Khouri
Mort Laitner
Donald Low
Ali Fathollah-Nejad
Nikkei Editorial
visit website
